Fresh Baked Pies

If you are already an Andersen Farms customer then your mouth is already watering from the mention of our amazing pies​​​​​​​​​! We have to admit that we don't bake them ourselves... but why mess with a good thing? The Clove Brook Bakery in Sussex, NJ fresh bakes all of our pies and breads from scratch. Yes, they are to-die-for and yes, you will want to eat the whole pie yourself! So the next time you are having company or you are just simply craving some American comfort food, come on down and get yourself a pie!


The pie selection varies from day to day but if you have a favorite just let us know and we will get one for you!


  • Summer Smash

  • Dutch Apple

  • Old Fashion Apple

  • Pumpkin

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Peach

  • Peach Blueberry

  • Peach Raspberry

  • Morning Glory

  • Blueberry

  • Pumpkin, Apple

  • Almond

  • Zucchini

  • Banana

  • Lemon


  • Winter Smash

  • Swedish Apple Walnut

  • Cranberry Apple

  • Cherry Raspberry

  • Blueberry

  • Very Berry

  • Strawberry Rhubarb

thanksgiving pies

We are now taking Thanksgiving Pie Orders! Orders need to be placed by Friday Nov 10th. Pick up at our Rt. 15 Sparta location ONLY from 9 a.m. - 5 p.m. on Tuesday Nov 21st & Wed. Nov 22nd. 


NO REFUNDS for pies not picked up & NO EXCEPTIONS for pick up location.

We will NOT be open on Thanksgiving

  • Apple

  • Pumpkin

  • Dutch Apple Crumb

  • Swedish Apple Walnut

  • Winter Smash

  • Cherry Raspberry

  • Caramel Apple Pecan

  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

Sussex Garden Center

212 RT-23   

Sussex, NJ 07461  


Sparta Farm Stand

Rt. 15 (across from the Bagel Station)  

Sparta, NJ 07871


Andover Farm Stand

209 Newton Sparta Rd. 

Newton, NJ 07860