ice cream shop

Farm-Fresh Taste the difference

Since opening inside our Sparta Store in 2020, the Andersen Farms Ice Cream Shop has created over 250 flavors in the last 5 years with every scoop made from scratch with our own time-tested recipes. Classic mainstays like Vanilla, Chocolate, Strawberry, Mint Chip, Judy’s Coffee, Black Raspberry 3x Chocolate Chunk, Pop’s Chocolate Chip, and Double Cookies & Cream anchor the menu year-round, while new seasonal flavors roll in roughly every season.


We craft options for everyone: gluten-free, vegan, and sugar-free varieties taste just as rich as the originals. Try a signature sundae that showcases the latest seasonal pick, or grab pints and quarts to keep the freezer stocked at home. Craving something extra special?


Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, rewarding a soccer win, or simply cooling off after a farm visit, the Ice Cream Shop turns any stop at Andersen Farms into a sweet family moment.

New & Seasonal Flavors

A close up of a bowl of ice cream with a blueberry on top.
A scoop of ice cream in a bowl on a white background.
A scoop of pink and green ice cream in a bowl.
A close up of a scoop of ice cream on a plate.
A bowl of ice cream with a piece of cake in it.
A close up of a scoop of ice cream in a bowl.
A white plate topped with a scoop of chocolate ice cream
A white bowl filled with a scoop of orange ice cream
A scoop of chocolate ice cream with marshmallows in a bowl.
A bowl of chocolate and vanilla ice cream with chocolate chips.

Year-Round Flavors

A scoop of vanilla ice cream in a paper cup
A scoop of chocolate ice cream in a bowl on a white background
A close up of a scoop of ice cream in a bowl
A scoop of mint chocolate chip ice cream in a bowl
A scoop of pink ice cream in a white bowl
A scoop of purple ice cream in a cup on a white background.
A close up of a scoop of ice cream in a bowl.
A close up of a scoop of ice cream in a bowl

sugar-Free flavors

A scoop of mint chocolate chip ice cream in a bowl
A close up of a scoop of ice cream on a white background

vegan non-dairy flavors

A scoop of vanilla ice cream in a paper cup
A scoop of pink ice cream in a white bowl
A white plate topped with a scoop of chocolate ice cream
A white bowl filled with a scoop of orange ice cream
A close up of a scoop of ice cream in a bowl
A bowl of blue ice cream with sprinkles on top.

milkshakes, slushees, malts & floats

A person is holding a milkshake with a straw and a slice of lemon
A person is holding a milkshake with a straw in front of flowers.
A person is holding a cup of coffee with a smiley face on top.
A person is holding a cup of chocolate milkshake with whipped cream on top
A box of mom 's secret ice cream with flowers on it

Ice Cream Flights

Can't decide what flavor you want? Choose any 5 ice cream flavors and we will scoop them into tiny cups with lids and pack them into a cute little box to take home!

Want ice cream at your next event? We offer party favor cups with lids that make ice cream parties easy and fun!
Call for more information. Call to Order 973-383-8335.

Toppings

Strawberries
Blueberries
Cherries
Rainbow Sprinkles

Chocolate Sprinkles

Whipped Cream
Caramel

Hot Fudge
Cookie Dough
Peanut Butter

Marshmallow
Oreos
Reese's Cups
Gummy Bears
Gummy Worms

Other SPARTA STORE Offerings

A person is holding a cup of coffee in front of a plant.

Coffee Shop

Breathtaking colors of our planet
LEARN MORE
A dessert with ice cream , whipped cream , caramel sauce and chocolate sauce on a plate.

Ice Cream Shop

Portraits of people from around the globe
Button
A wooden table topped with a variety of fruits and vegetables.

Farm-In-A-Box

Stark beauty of desolate dunes
Button
A blue and white playground set with a slide , climbing wall , and bridge.

Swing Sets

Visual odyssey across continents
Button

SPARTA STORE LOCATION

Lafayette Rd, Woodruff's Gap, Sparta, NJ

973-383-8335

Monday — Saturday: 9am — 6pm
Sunday: 11am — 5pm